NEWS & INSIGHTS

Combatting Payroll Pirates: The Role of Compliant Payroll Providers

Team FCSA

Recent reports have highlighted the alarming involvement of several UK recruitment firms in tax avoidance schemes, putting workers at significant financial risk. These deceptive practices, often led by fraudulent operators, have not only endangered the financial stability of workers but have also undermined the integrity of the UK’s tax system.

We strongly condemn these dishonest actions and the “payroll pirates” responsible for them. These schemes, which misclassify earnings as loans to avoid tax obligations, exploit legal loopholes and leave workers exposed to substantial back taxes when HMRC steps in to reclaim unpaid tax.

In contrast, Specialist Payroll Intermediaries (SPIs), such as umbrella companies, serve an essential function within the UK’s workforce by offering compliant, ethical employment solutions to contractors and freelancers. Working with a regulated SPI provides many benefits, including:

  • Tax Compliance: Ensuring all tax and National Insurance contributions are accurately deducted and paid to HMRC, protecting workers from unexpected tax bills.
  • Administrative Ease: Managing payroll, tax calculations, and other administrative responsibilities, allowing contractors to focus on their core work rather than complex financial issues.
  • Employment Rights: Offering statutory benefits such as holiday pay, sick pay, and pension contributions, delivering protections akin to those of traditional employees.
  • IR35 Compliance: Helping contractors navigate the complexities of IR35 legislation and ensuring they remain compliant with tax laws, reducing the risk of misclassification.


We urge all contractors and freelancers to carefully assess any payroll provider they engage with. Choosing companies that are accredited by respected industry bodies, such as the Freelancer and Contractor Services Association (FCSA) and Professional Passport, provides assurance of their adherence to ethical standards and legal compliance.

Additionally, we call on recruitment agencies to thoroughly vet any SPIs they partner with and recommend, ensuring these providers meet the necessary legal and ethical criteria. By rejecting the temptations of tax avoidance schemes and embracing compliant solutions, we can protect workers, safeguard the integrity of the tax system, and build a fairer, more transparent employment market.

About the author