News & insights

Umbrella vs Agency PAYE: What’s Best for You?

Team FCSA
umbrella vs agency paye thumbnail
This article was published before November 2026. At that time, FCSA described its Members as “accredited”. FCSA is now accredited by UKAS (No. 29551) to ISO/IEC 17065, and its Members are FCSA Certified Members, assessed against the FCSA Codes of Compliance. Some details in this article may also no longer be current.

Updated November 2026. This guide has been rewritten to reflect current rules, including the PAYE changes for labour supply chains from April 2026.

If you find temporary work through an agency, you will usually be paid in one of two ways: directly by the agency through its own payroll (agency PAYE), or through an umbrella company that employs you. Both are legitimate. This guide explains the differences so you can make an informed choice.

Agency PAYE

The agency pays you through its own payroll and deducts income tax and National Insurance under PAYE. You do not have to manage your own tax.

  • You are usually a worker rather than an employee of the agency.
  • Workers are entitled to the National Minimum Wage, paid holiday, Statutory Sick Pay, automatic pension enrolment (subject to age and earnings) and the rights under the Agency Workers Regulations.
  • Your contract usually lasts for the assignment.

Umbrella company

The umbrella company employs you, usually on an overarching contract of employment, and pays you through PAYE. The agency pays the umbrella an assignment rate, and the umbrella deducts its employment costs and margin before calculating your gross pay.

  • As an employee, you have employee rights as well as worker rights, subject to any qualifying periods.
  • You keep the same employer across assignments with different agencies, which some people find useful for continuity.
  • The Agency Workers Regulations still apply. After 12 weeks in the same role with the same hirer, the agency is responsible for making sure you receive equal treatment.

Comparing pay

The assignment rate quoted for umbrella work is normally higher than an agency PAYE rate for the same role, because it has to cover employer National Insurance, employer pension contributions, the Apprenticeship Levy where it applies, holiday pay in some cases, and the umbrella’s margin. Compare the take-home pay shown in each Key Information Document, not the headline rate.

Neither route offers special tax advantages. Since 2016, most umbrella employees cannot get tax relief on travel to their assignment, and anyone promising higher take-home pay through expenses or “allowances” should be treated with caution.

Recent changes

  • From 6 April 2026, the agency, or in some cases the end client, can be made to pay PAYE that an umbrella company fails to account for (GOV.UK guidance).
  • The Employment Rights Act 2025 will bring umbrella companies within the rules that govern employment businesses, enforced by the Fair Work Agency. This is due to take effect in December 2027.
  • Since 6 April 2026, Statutory Sick Pay is payable from the first day of sickness, and the lower earnings limit no longer applies.

Which suits you?

Agency PAYE is the simplest option if your agency offers it. An umbrella company can suit people who move between agencies or who want the continuity and employee status it brings. Whichever you choose:

  • ask for your Key Information Document before you start, and check that your payslips match it
  • if you use an umbrella company, check whether it is an FCSA Accredited Member

Find an FCSA Accredited umbrella company

About the author